I absolutely love baking Christmas cookies! For the past few years, I’ve tried to figure out how to make Harry Potter twists on my favorite recipes.

Peanut blossoms are one my favorites each year and I thought it’d be cool to turn the Hershey’s kisses into sorting hats! I incorporated each house into my recipe and swapped the peanut butter dough for sugar cookie dough to complement the sprinkle flavor 😊

Like I’ve said before I’m not a huge bake from scratch person. For this recipe I used pre-made dough because the easier, the better right?

Give these a shot- they’re perfect for a Harry Potter holiday party!


Sorting Hat Cookies
Write a review
  1. red sprinkles
  2. blue sprinkles
  3. green sprinkles
  4. yellow sprinkles
  5. sugar cookie dough
  6. Hershey’s kisses
  1. Carve the sorting hat face into the Hershey’s kisses.
  2. Pour each individual sprinkle color onto their own bowl.
  3. Roll the sugar cookie dough into balls.
  4. Coat the sugar cookie dough balls each with different colored sprinkles.
  5. Bake sugar cookies according to package directions.
  6. After baking, immediately top each cookie with a sorting hat!
Simply Potter https://simplypotter.com/

Video Tutorial


Be sure to like on us Facebook to keep up to date on exciting things from the Wizarding World!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )
Subscribe to get Harry Potter craft tutorials, recipe videos, breaking news, and travel guides/tips straight to your inbox!
Avada kedavra spam! Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.