I’m back with my first recipe since Christmas when I made sorting hat Christmas cookies! I’m currently in Boulder, Colorado where my friends were nice enough to let me use their kitchen to create this frozen butterbeer recipe. Currently, I’m travelling the country full time and making recipes in a camper van is just a little difficult 😂 I do plan on doing more soon so drop a comment below and let me know what you’d like to see!

For my first recipe in awhile, I decided to do something butterbeer related. Butterbeer is my absolute favorite and I was reminiscing about my favorite recipe to date, my butterbeer pancakes, so I decided to attempt to recreate my favorite Wizarding World treat- frozen butterbeer. 🍺

The frozen butterbeer was super easy to make and there are only 4 ingredients! For this recipe, you’ll need a blender and an ice tray. 👩🏻‍🍳

If you make your own, be sure to snap some photos and upload them to Instagram with the hashtag #simplypotter to be featured on my Instagram stories for Feature Friday!

Some tips:

⚡The longer you can freeze your cream soda, the less like a slushie your frozen butterbeer will be. I like mine a little slushie, so I froze mine for about 5 hours.
⚡After blending, test out your cream soda before adding the butter and rum extracts. If you want it a bit sweeter, splash in some extra cream soda.

frozen butterbeer pinterest graphic
















1-2 cans of cream soda
3/4 tsp butter extract
1/2 tsp rum extract
whipped cream

1. Freeze cream soda in ice tray for 5 hours
2. Blend frozen cream soda cubes
3. Splash in some extra cream soda
4. Add 3/4 tsp of butter extract
5. Add 1/2 tsp of rum extract
6. Blend together
7. Top with whipped cream


Video Tutorial


If you can’t get enough Harry Potter, drop your email below! I send out a weekly news letter and tell you about all things happening in the Wizarding World. Also, a few giveaways find there way into your inbox too 😉

For daily Potter updates, head over to the Facebook page and give it a like!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )
Subscribe to get Harry Potter craft tutorials, recipe videos, breaking news, and travel guides/tips straight to your inbox!
Avada kedavra spam! Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.